No, all Souls games are not directly connected in a single, continuous narrative. While they share thematic and mechanical similarities, each title usually inhabits its own distinct world with a unique lore.
The question hangs in the air, a topic fiercely debated among dedicated fans: are all souls games connected? It’s a valid point, given the recurring motifs and the similar feelings the different games evoke. Players explore a broken world, fight challenging enemies, and piece together fragmented stories.
Many elements give an impression of a shared universe. Yet, each game presents a unique narrative that is separate from the others. Exploring this can be quite fun for fans and those new to the genre.
Are All Souls Games Connected?
The world of “Souls-like” games, those tough-as-nails action RPGs inspired by FromSoftware’s groundbreaking Demon’s Souls and Dark Souls series, is full of mysteries. Players often wonder if these games, with their similar themes, gameplay, and even some recurring items and characters, are all secretly linked. Are we seeing a shared universe, or are they just clever nods to each other? Let’s delve deep and explore this intriguing question.
The FromSoftware Formula
Before we jump into connections, it’s important to understand what makes a “Souls” game. FromSoftware, the main developer behind most of these titles, has a specific style. They often include:
- Challenging combat: Expect to die. A lot. These games are known for their difficulty, requiring players to learn enemy attack patterns and manage resources carefully.
- Atmospheric world building: Each world is full of detailed environments, crumbling architecture, and a strong sense of dread.
- Fragmented storytelling: The narratives aren’t always laid out clearly. You often have to piece together the lore through item descriptions, character dialogue, and environmental details.
- Character customization: Players have many options for how their character looks and fights.
- Online interaction: Players can leave messages for each other, and even summon others for help, making these normally solo games a more social experience.
These common elements create a sense of familiarity across the different games, even when the stories and settings seem unique.
Direct Connections: The Dark Souls Trilogy
The clearest connections exist within the Dark Souls trilogy itself. These games share a direct timeline and many characters. For instance, events from Dark Souls have a direct impact on Dark Souls II, and later, Dark Souls III. Here’s a quick breakdown:
Dark Souls
The first game introduces the concept of the “Age of Fire” and the “Undead Curse”. The player, the Chosen Undead, must decide whether to rekindle the fire or let it fade.
Dark Souls II
This game takes place long after the events of Dark Souls, in a different kingdom. While the land is new, many themes carry over, including the cycles of light and dark. Many speculate the land itself might be a decaying part of Lordran, or part of other kingdoms affected by the events of the first game.
Dark Souls III
The trilogy concludes in this game, directly continuing the themes and story of the previous two. Players travel through lands clearly connected to the first two games and encounter many familiar faces. The choices made at the end of Dark Souls III are clearly tied to the series’ established story.
The Dark Souls trilogy is without a doubt, a unified tale, even if each game has its own story and setting.
Indirect Connections: Themes and Concepts
Moving beyond the Dark Souls trilogy, the connections become less direct but still noticeable. Many “Souls” games share similar themes, concepts, and even characters, suggesting a possible shared “multiverse”. Let’s examine this:
Cycles and Rebirth
Many of these games deal with cycles of life, death, and rebirth. In Dark Souls it’s the cycle of fire and dark, in Bloodborne it’s the dream and the waking world, and in Elden Ring it’s the shattering of the Elden Ring and the rise of the Tarnished. This recurring theme suggests that these events might be linked by an underlying concept or universal rule. Even in titles like Sekiro, death and resurrection play a key role, further solidifying this concept.
The Nature of Gods and Beings of Great Power
Another common thread is the presence of powerful entities, often seen as gods or deities. These beings can have great influence over the world and are often the source of major conflict. In Dark Souls there is Gwyn and the Lords, Bloodborne has Great Ones, and Elden Ring has the Outer Gods. These entities, while unique to each game, share similarities in their impact on the story and how they are perceived by characters in the world.
Recurring Characters and Items
Some names and items pop up repeatedly across different “Souls” games. Patches, the treacherous character who often kicks players down into traps, appears in nearly every game from FromSoftware. This might be just a fun nod from developers, but it fuels the idea of a hidden connection. Similar-looking weapons, armor, and even spells appear, sometimes with new or different names but with the same general effects. These instances could be simple Easter eggs, or they could hint at a shared history or origin.
The Idea of “Worlds” and “Dimensions”
Many of these games, especially Bloodborne and Elden Ring, deal with dimensions or dream worlds that exist parallel to the main reality. This opens the door for theories that all games take place in different layers or dimensions that are linked in a way that we can’t see. When dealing with dream or supernatural entities, the barrier between worlds might be thinner, allowing characters, items and even concepts to bleed into one another.
The Use of the “Moon”
The moon plays a prominent role in many FromSoftware games. In Bloodborne, the moon and its influence are directly woven into the game’s story and lore. While not always as direct, the moon’s presence is often notable in other titles, too. It might be just a symbol for the mysterious and unknowable, or it could hint at a deeper cosmic connection, even across different game worlds.
Specific Cases: Looking at the Evidence
Let’s examine some specific games outside of the Dark Souls trilogy:
Bloodborne
Set in the Victorian-era city of Yharnam, Bloodborne introduces eldritch horrors and the concept of the “Great Ones”. Many theorize the Great Ones are in some way connected to the gods and deities of other FromSoftware titles. It also introduces the idea of dream worlds and the blurring line between reality and the subconscious. It has different mechanics and weapons from the Souls series, making the connection feel more thematic than direct.
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Sekiro departs from the traditional RPG structure of the other games with an emphasis on stealth and sword combat. While it does not directly share characters or places with the others, it has a similar underlying tone and a focus on resurrection and the cost of immortality. The game uses a different kind of world, based on Japanese folklore, which makes any direct connection harder to find, however the overall storytelling method and challenging combat, place this game squarely among the others.
Elden Ring
Elden Ring expands on many concepts found in previous games. The Elden Ring, a source of power that governs the Lands Between, is a concept similar to the fire in the Dark Souls games. The Outer Gods of Elden Ring bear thematic similarities to the Great Ones of Bloodborne. Many items and equipment also have names and appearances that make players think of previous games. It makes the connection feel more apparent even if it is not a shared direct narrative.
Theories and Interpretations
There are many theories about the connections between these games. Here are some of the most popular:
The Shared Dream Theory
This theory proposes that all the games exist within a shared dream or subconscious, with each game being a different manifestation or layer of that dream. This idea is supported by the dreamlike quality of many of these games and their frequent use of cycles and rebirth.
The Multiverse Theory
The idea that the worlds are all different dimensions that exist parallel to each other, connected by certain cosmic forces or events. This would allow the games to remain separate but allow for recurring concepts and characters to appear in different forms across various dimensions. It explains why there are similar elements but no direct connection.
The Metaphorical Connection Theory
This theory suggests that all of these “Souls” games are not actually connected in a literal sense, but are rather related through shared themes, storytelling techniques, and philosophical concepts. They are more like explorations of similar ideas, rather than chapters in a larger, unified story.
Why Are These Connections Important?
The speculation about connections in Souls games adds to their overall mystery. It encourages players to look closely at the details, analyze the lore, and develop their own interpretations. Even if there’s no single, definitive answer, the questions add to the fun of experiencing these complex and challenging games.
The games’ stories are open to interpretation and speculation, which is a key part of what makes them so engaging. These kinds of questions allow players to explore, discuss and theorize about these games long after the end credits roll.
Ultimately, the question of whether all Souls games are connected is not one with a definitive answer. FromSoftware deliberately keeps the connections ambiguous, allowing players to interpret the evidence as they see fit. Whether you believe in a shared multiverse, a common dream, or simply thematic similarities, the act of questioning and theorizing is a significant part of what makes the “Souls-like” genre so captivating.
The evidence suggests there are strong thematic links, recurring elements and some clear connections (like the Dark Souls series), while others are left to the imagination and interpretation. It’s part of the magic of these games, to speculate and let the mystery live on.
Could All of FromSoftware's Games Be Connected!? INSANE Theory! ( Elden Ring, Dark Souls & More )
Final Thoughts
Ultimately, the connection between souls games remains debatable. Some subtle recurring themes and items suggest a shared universe. We see echoes of lore, hinting at potential links, yet nothing definitive.
However, explicit story connections are rare, mainly relying on player interpretation. The question of whether are all souls games connected might never have a simple answer. It’s a mystery, part of what makes these worlds so compelling.
