The “mistake” in The Westing Game is actually Sam Westing himself; he orchestrated the entire game, manipulating events and identities.
The question of who is the mistake in The Westing Game has puzzled many readers since its publication. It’s a central part of the mystery, leading us through a web of clues, characters, and secrets. The game is filled with complex relationships and hidden motives, making it difficult to pinpoint one single error. We are constantly trying to figure things out.
However, the key to answering who is the mistake in The Westing Game lies in understanding the very nature of the game itself. It is a carefully constructed puzzle, designed with a specific purpose in mind. The answer is quite unexpected when you find out the truth.
Who Is the Mistake in The Westing Game?
The mystery at the heart of The Westing Game isn’t just about who killed Samuel Westing; it’s about the real identity of the “mistake.” That mistake isn’t a simple error, but rather a carefully planned element of Westing’s complex puzzle. Let’s dive deep into figuring out who this mistake truly is. We will explore all the potential candidates, their motives and the evidence in Raskin’s masterful novel.
Understanding the “Mistake”
Before we pinpoint the character, it’s essential to grasp what the term “mistake” implies within the context of the book. It’s not someone who made an accidental blunder. It’s a person strategically positioned by Samuel Westing to act as a key piece of his game. This individual is not just a random participant; they are integral to Westing’s larger plan, which is to bring people together and help them confront their own pasts and potential. Think of it like a secret ingredient in a recipe – not a flaw, but something that completes the flavor.
The Obvious Suspects: The Heirs
The initial focus of the game is on the sixteen heirs, each paired with another. Each pair receives clues that lead them through twists and turns, making each person a potential mistake. But are they really just mistakes? Let’s look at some of them more closely.
Turtle Wexler
Turtle, the young and feisty protagonist, is initially considered a strong contender for being the mistake due to her intelligence and knack for cracking codes. However, as the story unfolds, we learn that she is less of a mistake and more of a crucial player. Westing knew her sharp mind could potentially solve the mystery. Her tendency to kick anyone who touched her braid shows her protective nature, and this adds to her unique character. She’s a force to be reckoned with, making her a powerful pawn rather than an accidental one.
Flora Baumbach
The sweet and caring dressmaker, Flora Baumbach, also appears to be a possible mistake at first glance. She is paired with Turtle, and this makes her important. Her gentle nature might seem like she wouldn’t be part of any trickery. But later we understand the importance of her presence. Her past sorrow and her present kindness make her less of a mistake and more of a calming presence in the high stakes game.
Judge J.J. Ford
A powerful and insightful judge, J.J. Ford initially seems above suspicion because of her position and intelligence. However, her past connection with Samuel Westing makes her a suspect. She is one of the few people who had a personal relationship with him. But her goal is to find out who killed Westing. So, her character becomes more like a detective in the story rather than a mistake. She is also trying to repay her debt. She uses her intelligence and her detective skills to help resolve the game, making her important to the plot’s resolution.
Other Heirs
The other heirs, such as Grace Wexler, Angela Wexler, Chris Theodorakis, Doug Hoo, and Sydelle Pulaski also appear to be potential “mistakes” at various points. Each heir has their own secrets and motivations. Some are trying to claim the inheritance, some want to start new lives. Each of these characters, with their different problems and hopes, are necessary to make Westing’s game work. They are not mistakes, but important characters in the story.
The Real “Mistake”: Sam Westing Himself
The ultimate reveal at the end of the book is that the real “mistake” is none other than Samuel Westing himself. Or rather, his many identities. He’s the mastermind behind the entire game, playing multiple roles to achieve his specific goals. He manipulates everyone, not out of malice, but to push them towards personal growth and resolution.
Westing’s Multiple Identities
Westing’s genius is displayed through the use of alter egos. He fakes his death and appears in different forms. He was not just one character but several, all working together to conduct the game.
- Samuel Westing: The wealthy, eccentric businessman who supposedly died at the beginning of the story.
- Barney Northrup: The real estate agent who sold the apartments in Sunset Towers. This character is actually Sam Westing himself in disguise.
- Julian R. Eastman: The unassuming, kindly old man who also happens to be Samuel Westing living in another form.
- Sandy McSouthers: The doorman, who seemed so ordinary but was Westing once again, who was in the game to guide the players
Why Westing is the “Mistake”
Westing, in his various forms, is the ultimate mistake because his deception is the core of the entire game. He designed the puzzle, planted the clues, and controlled the movement of the heirs. He is not a mistake as in a blunder, but he is a strategic and planned “mistake.” His purpose is to test the heirs, to help them see their full potential, and also to find a successor. He also wants to reunite with his daughter. His actions serve to create an engaging and meaningful experience for everyone involved.
Westing’s Motivations
Westing’s motives were complex. He wasn’t looking to punish anyone. Instead, he wanted to create something meaningful for the people he had known and those he had just met. He wanted to do these things:
- Find a worthy successor: Westing needed someone to take over his company. He wanted someone intelligent and honest.
- Bring people together: Many of the heirs lived isolated lives. The game brought them together and helped them form relationships.
- Help people heal: Westing knew that many of the heirs carried burdens from their past. The game helped them face their demons.
- Reconnect with his daughter: He uses this game as a chance to connect with his daughter. Her presence in the game as Judge J.J. Ford is a hidden element in his strategy.
The Significance of the “Mistake”
The concept of the “mistake” in The Westing Game is a brilliant plot twist that keeps readers engaged until the very end. It is not just about solving a murder; it is about understanding the complex human relationships and the power of second chances. Westing’s deception is not just a cheap trick but a method to teach the characters and the readers about the importance of communication, honesty, and self-discovery.
A Lesson for the Heirs
For the heirs, the “mistake” taught them that things are not always what they seem. They learned that sometimes the most unexpected people are the most important. The game was not about the money; it was about growth and learning about themselves and each other. They came to understand their own strength and their connection with the world around them.
A Lesson for the Readers
The real “mistake” also serves as a valuable lesson for readers. It teaches us to look beyond the surface, to question assumptions, and to be open to unexpected possibilities. The story suggests that the real treasures of life are found not just in material wealth, but in relationships, personal growth, and understanding the people around us. The story makes us think about our own assumptions and how we approach problems.
The Power of Westing’s Plan
Westing’s plan, though complex, was also simple in its goal: to make everyone involved realize their own potential. By using the guise of a game and a fictional “mistake,” he created a lasting impact on the lives of the heirs. The game forced them out of their comfort zones and showed them the importance of community, friendship, and self-awareness. It was a very complex method of helping people move toward a more fulfilling life.
The “mistake” is an intricate part of Westing’s plan, not a flaw or error. He made an elaborate game where he was a central player, using different identities to manipulate the heirs towards his desired outcome. The outcome he desired was that everyone would gain from this game, not only one person or his desired successor. He ensured that everyone gets some sort of reward at the end of the game, and everyone gets to know about each other. This is why his game is so popular. He knew that the power of his game lies in the mystery. This makes it a captivating read from beginning to end.
Ultimately, “the mistake” in The Westing Game is a testament to Raskin’s genius in crafting a mystery that is both entertaining and profound. It forces us to look beyond the obvious and appreciate the underlying complexities of human nature and relationships. It’s not about a simple error; it’s about a deliberate act that propels the story forward and provides meaningful growth for all of its characters.
The worst book I bought because of BookTok
Final Thoughts
The mistaken identity in The Westing Game is actually Sam Westing himself. He faked his death and took on different personas. Sam’s elaborate game was a manipulation. He aimed to find a successor not just a killer.
This brings us to the question: who is the mistake in the westing game? It is a critical part of the overall plot. The answer is not about a wrong person, but rather the identity and intention of Sam. The game must also be considered when considering the mistake.
